Jagjit Singh is probably one of my most favorite singers (and my absolute favorite ghazal artiste). “Baat Niklegi To Phir Door Talak Jayegi” has always been one of my favorites but for some reason its been stuck in my head last few days. I thought I’d try to post a translation because I think its just such wonderful, poignant, lovely poetry. I love when my brother sings this one…
Because this is difficult Urdu for me, a lot will be lost in translation, and there are certain words that even I had to hunt. But hopefully some one out there will still appreciate it, because a lot of people stumble here looking for Jagjit Singh’s translations (I’ve posted some ghazals before, organized under categories). Please let me know if you have any alternate suggestions/thoughts about my translation or just about the ghazal itself. Its just so beautiful…short, but quite, quite lovely, especially in Jagjit Singh’s wonderful voice.
The translation itself may not make as much sense if you don’t get the gist of the song or the feeling behind it, or understand the voice of the writer. The wonderful thing about ghazals is that they may be interpreted so many different ways. My own analysis of this piece is as follows…it is a poem of admonition, where a lover warns his beloved about how the world will never understand their love. When the word (baat) goes out (niklegi) it will spread like wildfire (door talak jayegi), rumors and gossip about their relationship will be tossed around, it will be the talk of the town, but no one will understand. We learn that she is seperated from him, that this separation is painful, visible by the way she has stopped to take care of herself, stopped to do her hair, wash her face, visible by how she has aged, by the bangles she wears. And people, they notice all this, they conjecture on it, they gossip about her and her condition and the reason behind it, they may taunt her, be cruel to her by noticing all these faults and asking her persistently. They may bring up his name in conversation just to see her reaction for their own entertainment. But, he warns, don’t be dragged into it…don’t answer back, or question, or argue, or let it show on your face how much you love me. If you say anything, the expression on your face will give it all away, so be quiet, and bear it, and don’t talk about me with anyone. Because once the word gets out…it will go too far.
Feel free to post elswhere, but credit moi.
Baat Niklegi To Phir, by Jagjit Singh. Written by Kafeel Azar.
Baat Niklegi To Phir…Door Talak Jayegi
(If word goes out, it will spread too far)
Log Bewajah, Udasi Ka Sabab Poochenge
(People will, without reason, probe at the cause behind your sorrow)
Yeh Bhi Poochenge, Ki Tum Itni Pareshan Kyun Ho
(They will also ask about why you are so troubled)
Ungliyan Uthengi, Sookhe Baalon Ki Taraf
(Fingers will be raised to your dry [unwashed] hair)
Ek Nazar Dekhenge, Guzreh Huye Saalon Ki Taraf
(There will glance suspiciously at the years gone by)
Chudiyon Pe Bhi, Kayi Tanz Kiye Jayenge
(Even your bangles will become the subject of jokes/wisecracks)
Kaapten Haathon Pe Bhi, Fikre Kase Jayenge
(Even the old and the aged, whose hands tremble, will not hesitate to taunt you…)*
*fikre, I think, means understanding or comprehension, and I think this line means that people will even make something out of nothing, just to talk about it. Even if your hand shakes, people will say it means something. That’s my take. Edited per Bhuwan’s comments: fikre means teasing or taunting
Log Zaalim Hai, Harek Baat Ka Taana Denge
(People are cruel, they will taunt you for every single thing)
Baaton Baaton Mein, Mera Zikr Bhi Le Aayenge (2)
(Somewhere in the conversation, they’ll mention me too)
Unki Baaton Ka Zara Sa Bhi Asar Mat Lena…
(Don’t give their words any significance [attention] at all…)
Warna Chehre Ke Tasur Se Samajh Jayenge
(Or the expression on your face will give it all away)
Chahe Kuch Bhi Ho, Sawaalat Na Karna Unse (2)
(No matter what happens, don’t question/argue with them)
Mere Baare Mein Koi Baat Na Karna Unse
(Don’t talk about me with them)
Baat Niklegi To Phir…Door Talak Jayegi
(If word goes out…it will spread too far)

Nice Attempt Friend!……………
I have one amendment______
Kampte hathon se bhi fikre kase jayenge
Means to say that
Even those who are aged and fed up with themselves, their weary bodies………….
even they will not lag behind in taunting
Fikre- you are right in saying it as meaning taunting or eve teasing!
I am done!
May God Bless You!
Keep Smiling bcoz ………….
Though for smiling u need nt have any reason……….
But even then for the sake of satisfying the questioning mind…….
Bcoz……….Smiles travel and they reach out to those whom You Love!
Thank you Bhuwan! Your interpretation makes sense. Appreciate your words.
That stuff was very nice. My best Jagjit Singh song is hazaaro khwahishe aisi… The good thing about it is that everyone can relate to it in some way or the other. And the way it has been sung into a song…
Hi Mitasha,
Thanks for the lyrics and translation. Please listen to my cover version of the gazal at http:bahuvreehi.blogspot.com
I have pasted the lyrics and translation in my blog, Thanks again.
Please refer to this line :
Kaampten Haathon Pe Bhi, Fikre Kase Jayenge
Dear friend :My understanding of this line is different :
Yahan jin hathon ka zikar hai woh khud Mehbooba kay hath
hain.
My understanding is :
Kaampten Haathon Pe Bhi : On her (beloved – Mehbooba’s) trembling hands too
Fikre Kase Jayenge : Taunts shall be commented upon
Whole line is :
On her(beloved- Mehbooba’s) trembling hands too,Taunts shall be commented upon
Regards
Sanjay
I agree with Sanjay’s comment above on who do the “Kaapte hath” belong to.
Also, I interpret the 1st line a little differently. “Baat niklegi toh fir door talak jaayegi”…here “door talak” points to the extent to which such conversations could go to. The word spreading too far could have been a possible meaning but the next few lines do not really support it.
A nice interpretation,
but you have used the literal meaning of some lines,
and metaphorical meaning of some lines…….
Poets who write about the longings of the lovers usually compare it to earthly, worldly daily routine activites to make it more impressive….
baat nikelegi toh phir door talaq jaayegi…
if the conversation gets started, then it will be dissected beyond measure,
sookhen baalon ki taraf…..
more than unwashed, its to imply the unkept hair (look)
tanz is taunt or taana….
Kayi fiqre kase jaayenge….
fiqre is a plural of fiqra,
fiqra actually refers to a paragraph or few sentences…
though the poet actually means to say ” taunt” indeed.
using a hindu or urdu word that directly means a taunt, in this line would have demystified the meaning and the beauty of the portrayal of this nazm.
JS usually sings ghazals, but sometimes he sings nazms, punjabi tappe, and bhajans also…..
loved the way you interpreted this line….
Warna Chehre Ke Tasur Se Samajh Jayenge
(Or the expression on your face will give it all away
and loved the way, he has used so many different sounding words, just for the sake of implying “taana” in this nazm.
just wondering, how do you find time for blog, being in medschool…
Thank you, I appreciate your comments
You may have noted this blog has not been updated regularly (and not in a while)…that is an unfortunate side effect of being a medical student, actually!
Thanks for stopping by!
have not completely read your blog yet,
planning to read it as and when i get time,
but yes i realised you were not updating it regularly,
thought you were over medschool,
but guess you doing your residency
Dear docmitasha,
I found your translation very awesome. The way you have translated this poem indicates your language skills and abilities very well. just on this line Kaapten Haathon Pe Bhi, Fikre Kase Jayenge I would agree with Sanjay. With respect to the word fekre it should be noted that literally this word means thought or understanding, orginally derived from Arabic but is used in persian Pashtu and Urdu Languages. It can be used here as taunt as well. even if you with the literal meaning it will make sense.
Once again I appreciate your translation and in the future I will ask you about meaning and translation of some words or sentences. I am from Afghanistan I speak Pashtu and Dari (persian), but I like Urdu-Hindi very much.
Best of luck for your studies.
With Respect
Jawed
Dear docmitasha,
I found your translation very awesome. The way you have translated this poem indicates your language skills and abilities very well. just on this line Kaapten Haathon Pe Bhi, Fikre Kase Jayenge I would agree with Sanjay. With respect to the word fekre it should be noted that literally this word means thought or understanding, orginally derived from Arabic but is used in persian Pashtu and Urdu Languages. It can be used here as taunt as well. even if you go with the literal meaning it will make sense.
Once again I appreciate your translation and in the future I will ask you about meaning and translation of some words or sentences. I am from Afghanistan I speak Pashtu and Dari (persian), but I like Urdu-Hindi very much.
Best of luck for your studies.
With Respect
Jawed
Very nice attempt. The trmbling hands are those of the singer’s beloved, not those of the tormentors.
Please email me with any tips about how you made your blog site look this cool , Id be thankful.
The design for your blog is a tad off in Epiphany. Nevertheless I like your site. I may have to use a normal web browser just to enjoy it.
This blog has got a lot of really helpful stuff on it! Thank you for informing me!
As soon as I originally left a comment I clicked on the Notify me when new comments are added checkbox and now each time a comment is added I receive four messages with the identical comment.
Wanted to drop a comment and let you know your Feed is not functioning today. I tried adding it to my Bing reader account and got absolutely nothing.
How come you dont have your web site viewable in wap format? cant see anything in my phone.
I tried taking a look at your web site with my blackberry and the layout does not seem to be correct. Might wanna check it out on WAP as well as it seems most mobile phone layouts are not working with your web page.
I Am Going To have to come back again when my course load lets up – nonetheless I am taking your Rss feed so i can read your internet site offline. Cheers.
Just to let you know your blog appears a little bit different on Safari on my computer using Linux .
This website is really cool. How did you make it !?
quite beneficial material, all in all I picture this is worthy of a book mark, thanks
A cool post there mate ! Thanks for posting !
This website has a lot of really helpful information on it. Thank you for informing me!
Can you email me with some pointers about how you made your blog site look like this , I would be thankful.
This is really a excellent site, would you be interested in working on an interview about just how you designed it? If so e-mail myself!
It appears to me that this website doesnt load on a Motorola Droid. Are other people having the exact same issue? I enjoy this website and dont want to have to miss it whenever Im away from my computer.
When I start your Rss feed it appears to be a lot of nonsense, is the issue on my part?
Many of the remarks on this site dont make sense.
Hi, I just hopped over to your site through StumbleUpon. Not somthing I would typically browse, but I appreciated your views none the less. Thank you for creating some thing well worth reading through.
I believe one of your current ads triggered my web browser to resize, you might well need to set up that on your blacklist.
Good Stuff, do you currently have a flickr account?